If you love the bold, architectural look of agave plants but need something a bit different, you’re not alone. Many gardeners seek out plants that look like agave for their similar dramatic form but often with more flexibility. These succulents offer the same striking silhouette, often with varied hardiness or growth habits, making them perfect for creating that sculptural garden look.
Plants That Look Like Agave
This group of succulents shares the classic agave traits: a rosette form, often with spiny edges, and a preference for sunny, well-drained spots. However, they belong to different botanical families or genera. Knowing these look-alikes helps you choose the right plant for your climate and design, especially if you want a similar aesthetic without the massive size or monocarpic nature of some true agaves.
Why Choose an Agave Look-Alike?
You might opt for a similar plant for several good reasons. Some are more cold-hardy, while others stay smaller for containers. A few lack the sharp terminal spine, making them safer for gardens with children or pets. They let you achieve that desired look with more options.
- Hardiness: Many tolerate colder winters than typical agaves.
- Size Control: Perfect for smaller spaces or pots.
- Safety: Some have softer leaves with less dangerous spines.
- Availability: They can be easier to find at local nurseries.
Top Succulents That Mimic Agave
Here are the most common and reliable plants that give you that agave style. Each has its own unique character and growing requirements.
1. Furcraea (Furcraea spp.)
Often called “false agave,” Furcraea is perhaps the most convincing doppelgänger. It forms large, stunning rosettes of sword-shaped leaves. The main difference is in the flower stalk; Furcraea produces branched panicles with bell-shaped flowers, unlike agave’s single spike.
- Key Trait: Looks almost identical but flowers differently.
- Hardiness: Slightly less cold-tolerant than some agaves.
- Great For: A dramatic focal point in warm climates.
2. Beschorneria
This one is sometimes known as the “soft agave.” Its leaves are similar but lack the sharp teeth and terminal spine, feeling more fleshy and flexible. It’s a fantastic choice for a softer, more touch-friendly agave shape.
- Key Trait: Softer, spineless leaves on most species.
- Hardiness: Surprisingly cold-tolerant down to around 15°F.
- Great For: Gardens where safety is a concern.
3. Manfreda
Manfredas are close relatives of agaves but are generally smaller and have softer, often beautifully patterned or textured leaves. They are sometimes called “tuberoses.” Their flowers are also unique, rising on tall, interesting spikes.
- Key Trait: Smaller size and patterned, pliable foliage.
- Hardiness: Varies; some are quite cold-hardy.
- Great For: Container gardens or front-of-border interest.
4. Dracaena (Dracaena spp., like D. draco)
The Dragon Tree (Dracaena draco) starts life as a perfect agave-like rosette. As it matures, it forms a thick, woody trunk. The young plants are frequently mistaken for agaves and make excellent potted specimens for years before they begin to trunk.
- Key Trait: Starts as a rosette, eventually forms a tree.
- Hardiness: Tender; protect from frost.
- Great For: Long-term container growth or mild-climate landscapes.
5. Hechtia
Hechtias are terrestrial bromeliads that form tight, spiny rosettes very reminicent of agave. They are incredibly drought-tolerant and produce tall flower spikes from the center. Their foliage often has a silvery or reddish tint.
- Key Trait: Spiky rosettes; part of the bromeliad family.
- Hardiness: Fairly good cold tolerance for a bromeliad.
- Great For: Xeriscaping and rock gardens.
6. Dryland Bromeliads (Dyckia, Orthophytum)
These bromeliads are tough, sun-loving plants that form tight, often silvery rosettes with pronounced spines. They stay relatively small and are exceptional in pots or as ground cover in hot, dry areas. They multiply readily to form clusters.
- Key Trait: Small, clustering rosettes with sharp teeth.
- Hardiness: Varies; many can handle light frost.
- Great For: Small spaces, trough gardens, and hot spots.
How to Care for Agave-Like Succulents
While each plant has specific needs, their care is broadly similar due to their shared adaptation to dry environments. Following these general guidelines will set you up for success.
Sunlight and Placement
Almost all of these plants need full sun to look their best and maintain a compact form. At least six hours of direct sun is ideal. In extremely hot inland climates, some afternoon shade can prevent scorching, but this is rarely needed. Indoors, place them in your brightest window.
Soil and Drainage
This is the most critical factor. Fast-draining soil is non-negotiable. You can use a commercial cactus and succulent mix. For garden planting, amend heavy clay soil with plenty of gravel, pumice, or coarse sand to improve drainage dramatically. Wet roots lead to rot, which is the main cause of failure.
Watering Schedule
Water deeply but infrequently. The “soak and dry” method works perfectly.
- Water the plant thoroughly until water runs out the drainage hole.
- Allow the soil to dry out completely before watering again.
- In winter, reduce watering frequency by half or more, especially for outdoor plants in cool, wet climates.
Fertilizing Needs
These plants are light feeders. Too much fertilizer can cause weak, leggy growth. Use a balanced, diluted liquid fertilizer formulated for cacti and succulents once in early spring and once in midsummer. That’s usually enough to support healthy growth without overdoing it. Avoid fertilizing in fall and winter.
Design Ideas for Your Garden
Using these striking plants effectively can elevate your garden’s design. Their architectural shape provides great contrast.
- Focal Points: Use a large Furcraea or Beschorneria as a centerpiece in a bed.
- Container Gardens: Plant a Manfreda or small Hechtia in a pot for patio drama.
- Modern & Xeriscape Beds: Combine them with ornamental grasses, gravel, and boulders.
- Border Definition: Line a pathway with a repeating pattern of smaller Dyckia.
Common Problems and Solutions
Even tough plants have issues. Here’s how to troubleshoot.
- Soft, Mushy Leaves: A classic sign of overwatering or poor drainage. Check the roots for rot, cut away any dark, soft parts, and repot in dry, fresh mix.
- Pale, Stretched Growth: The plant is not getting enough light. Gradually move it to a sunnier location to prevent further etiolation.
- Brown Leaf Tips: Can be caused by sunburn (if sudden) or underwatering (if chronic). Adjust exposure or your watering schedule accordingly.
- Mealybugs or Scale: Treat these pests with a cotton swab dipped in rubbing alcohol or apply a horticultural oil like neem oil.
FAQ
What plant is similar to agave?
Many plants are similar, including Furcraea, Beschorneria, and Manfreda. These succulents share the rosette form but often differ in flower, hardiness, or leaf texture.
What is the succulent that looks like a small agave?
Manfreda and many Dryland Bromeliads like Dyckia are perfect small agave look-alikes. They offer the same shape at a scale suitable for pots or small garden spaces.
What is the difference between agave and yucca?
While both are rosette-forming, yuccas typically have thinner, more flexible leaves with thread-like filaments along the edges. Agave leaves are generally more rigid and succulent, with stout spines. Their flowers are also very different.
Is a century plant the same as agave?
Yes, “century plant” is a common name for Agave americana, a specific type of agave. Not all agaves are century plants, but all century plants are agaves.
Can these plants handle frost?
It depends on the species. Beschorneria and some Hechtia have good cold tolerance. Others, like Furcraea and Dracaena, are more tender. Always check the specific hardiness of your plant before a freeze is expected.