Choosing the right grass for your southern lawn is a big decision. Two of the most popular warm-season options are St. Augustine grass and Centipede grass. Understanding the key differences between st augustine grass vs centipede is essential for a healthy, beautiful yard that fits your lifestyle and local conditions.
Both grasses thrive in the heat and humidity of the southern United States, but they have distinct personalities. One is a fast-growing, lush carpet, while the other is a low-maintenance, slow-and-steady performer. Picking the wrong one can lead to years of unnecessary work, disappointment, and extra costs.
This guide will walk you through every detail. We’ll compare their appearance, climate needs, maintenance routines, and problem areas. By the end, you’ll know exactly which grass is the champion for your specific piece of the South.
St Augustine Grass vs Centipede
Let’s start with a broad overview of these two grasses. St. Augustine is known for its wide, flat blades and rapid, aggressive growth habit. It creates a thick, dense turf that feels wonderful underfoot. Centipede grass, often called “the lazy man’s grass,” has narrower, lighter green blades and a slower, creeping growth pattern. It’s prized for its minimal fertilizer needs and overall easy-going nature.
Here’s a quick snapshot of their core characteristics:
* St. Augustine Grass: Coarse texture, dark green color, fast growth, high shade tolerance, moderate drought tolerance, requires more feeding.
* Centipede Grass: Medium texture, light apple-green color, slow growth, poor shade tolerance, good drought tolerance, requires little feeding.
Appearance and Texture
The look and feel of your lawn matter. St. Augustine grass has broad, blunt-tipped blades that can be almost a quarter-inch wide. It forms a thick, carpet-like lawn that is notably soft and dense. This gives it a luxurious, full appearance that many homeowners love.
Centipede grass blades are more narrow and pointed. Its color is a distinctive light, apple-green or yellow-green, which sets it apart from the deeper greens of other southern grasses. The texture is finer than St. Augustine but coarser than Bermuda. It forms a relatively dense turf, but not as impenetrably thick as St. Augustine.
Growth Habit and Establishment
How these grasses spread is a major differentiator. St. Augustine grass is a vigorous, aggressive grower. It spreads primarily through above-ground runners called stolons. These stolons creep along the soil surface, quickly rooting and sending up new blades. This allows it to fill in bare spots fast and recover from damage.
Centipede grass spreads using both stolons and below-ground stems called rhizomes, though its stolons are more prominent. Its growth is decidedly slow and methodical. It won’t fill in a new lawn or repair itself as quickly as St. Augustine. This slow growth, however, means less frequent mowing.
Establishment Methods:
1. St. Augustine: Almost always established from sod, plugs, or sprigs. It is very rarely available as seed.
2. Centipede: Can be established from seed, sod, plugs, or sprigs. Seed is a common and cost-effective option.
Climate and Geographic Suitability
Both grasses need warm weather, but their ideal zones differ slightly. St. Augustine grass is highly tolerant of coastal conditions, including salt spray. It performs best in USDA zones 8-10, thriving along the Gulf Coast and throughout Florida. It can handle heat but may struggle in the cooler edges of the transition zone.
Centipede grass is a bit more cold-tolerant than St. Augustine, surviving further north into parts of the Carolinas and Arkansas (zones 7-10). However, it is less tolerant of salt. It excels in the acidic, sandy soils common across the Southeastern Piedmont region.
Shade Tolerance
This is one of St. Augustine’s biggest strengths. It has the best shade tolerance of all the warm-season grasses. While it still prefers sun, certain varieties can survive in areas with filtered light or several hours of daily shade. If your yard has large trees, St. Augustine is often the only viable option for a full lawn.
Centipede grass requires full sun to perform well. It will thin out and struggle in shaded areas, becoming weedy and patchy. For a lawn with significant tree cover, Centipede is usually not the best choice.
Maintenance Requirements Compared
Your willingness to care for your lawn is a deciding factor. Let’s break down the maintenance needs side-by-side.
Mowing Needs:
* St. Augustine: Should be mowed at a higher height, typically between 3.5 to 4 inches. Mowing too short can weaken it and invite weeds. Its fast growth means weekly mowing during peak season.
* Centipede: Prefers a height of 1.5 to 2 inches. Mowing it too high can lead to thatch problems. Its slow growth is a bonus here, often allowing for bi-weekly mowing schedules.
Watering Requirements:
Both grasses need about 1 inch of water per week during active growth. St. Augustine has a moderate drought tolerance but will go dormant and brown quickly during extended dry periods. It recovers well with irrigation.
Centipede grass has good drought tolerance and can survive dry spells, but it will also enter dormancy. A key warning: once Centipede turns brown from drought, it is slow to green back up. Consistent moisture is better for its appearance.
Fertilizing and Soil pH
This is a critical difference. St. Augustine grass is a heavier feeder. It typically needs 3-4 applications of nitrogen-rich fertilizer per growing season to maintain its vigor and dark color. It prefers a soil pH between 6.0 and 7.5.
Centipede grass is famous for needing very little fertilizer. In fact, over-fertilizing is the most common mistake made with this grass. One light application in late spring is often sufficient. It thrives in acidic soils with a pH between 5.0 and 6.0. Applying lime to a Centipede lawn can often do more harm than good.
Thatch and Aeration
* St. Augustine: Its vigorous stolon growth can lead to a thatch layer over time. Occasional dethatching or core aeration may be needed every few years if the thatch becomes too thick.
* Centipede: Is prone to thatch buildup, especially if over-fertilized or over-watered. Managing thatch through proper cultural practices is important for long-term Centipede health.
Pest and Disease Problems
No grass is immune to issues, but the challenges differ.
Common St. Augustine Problems:
* Chinch Bugs: This is the #1 insect pest. They suck sap from the grass, causing yellowing and dead patches.
* Brown Patch & Gray Leaf Spot: Fungal diseases that thrive in humid, wet conditions, often exacerbated by overwatering or poor drainage.
* St. Augustine Decline (SADV): A viral disease for which there is no cure. Using resistant varieties like ‘Floratam’ is crucial in areas where the virus is present.
Common Centipede Problems:
* Ground Pearl: An insect that causes circular dead patches. Control is very difficult.
* Centipede Decline: Not a single disease, but a syndrome often caused by poor soil conditions (high pH, compaction), over-fertilization, or overwatering.
* Nematodes: Microscopic worms that attack roots, leading to thin, weak turf, especially in sandy soils.
Durability and Traffic Tolerance
Think about how you use your yard. St. Augustine grass has moderate traffic tolerance. It can handle some family play but may wear down along frequent pathways. It recovers from damage fairly quickly due to its fast growth rate.
Centipede grass has low traffic tolerance. It is not suited for high-activity areas like sports fields or yards with heavy, daily play from kids and pets. It recovers from damage very slowly because it grows so slow.
Cost Analysis: Installation and Upkeep
Your budget is a practical concern. Initial installation for St. Augustine is usually more expensive because it is almost always laid as sod. This provides an instant lawn but at a higher upfront cost. Its ongoing costs are also higher due to increased fertilizer and potential pest control needs.
Centipede grass can be much cheaper to install if you use seed. Even as sod, it is often comparably priced. Its long-term upkeep costs are notably lower because of its minimal fertilizer requirements and reduced mowing frequency.
Making the Final Choice for Your Lawn
So, how do you decide? Ask yourself these questions:
Choose St. Augustine Grass If:
* Your lawn has partial to moderate shade.
* You want a lush, dark green, dense carpet quickly.
* You live near the coast or in a very hot, humid climate.
* You don’t mind a more involved fertilizing schedule.
* You have a budget for sod installation.
Choose Centipede Grass If:
* Your lawn gets full, all-day sun.
* You have acidic, sandy soil.
* You want the lowest-maintenance fertilizer regimen.
* You’re patient with establishment and recovery.
* Your lawn sees light to moderate foot traffic.
* You’re working with a tighter budget (using seed).
The best choice always considers your local conditions. I recommend talking to neighbors with great lawns or consulting your county extension office. They know the local soil, pest pressures, and which varieties perform best in your immediate area.
Planting and Care Checklists
Planting St. Augustine:
1. Test your soil pH and adjust to near neutral (6.0-7.5) if needed.
2. Prepare soil by tilling and removing weeds and rocks.
3. Install sod, plugs, or sprigs in late spring/early summer.
4. Water new plantings deeply and daily for the first two weeks.
5. Begin mowing when it reaches about 4 inches tall.
6. Apply a balanced fertilizer 4-6 weeks after planting.
Planting Centipede:
1. Test your soil pH. Ideally, it should be acidic (5.0-6.0). Do not add lime.
2. Prepare a fine seedbed if sowing seed.
3. Sow seed or install sod in late spring/early summer.
4. Keep soil consistently moist until seeds germinate or sod roots.
5. Mow for the first time when it reaches about 3 inches tall.
6. Wait until the following spring to apply a light fertilizer application.
FAQ Section
Which is better, St. Augustine or Centipede grass?
There’s no single “better” grass. St. Augustine is better for shade and a lush look with more upkeep. Centipede is better for full sun, acidic soil, and low fertilizer needs. The better grass is the one that matches your yard’s conditions and your maintenance preferences.
Can I mix St. Augustine and Centipede grass?
It’s not recommended. They have vastly different soil pH preferences, mowing height requirements, and growth rates. One will typically outcompete the other, leading to a patchy, uneven lawn that is difficult to care for properly.
Which grass is more soft?
St. Augustine grass is generally considered softer underfoot due to its wider, fleshier blades and dense growth habit. Centipede grass is not uncomfortable, but its texture is slightly more coarse.
What is the downside to centipede grass?
Its main downsides are poor shade tolerance, slow growth and recovery, vulnerability to “Centipede Decline” from improper care, and low tolerance for heavy foot traffic.
Does St. Augustine grass spread faster than Centipede?
Yes, significantly faster. St. Augustine is an aggressive, fast-growing grass that spreads quickly via above-ground runners. Centipede grass is known for its notably slow growth rate, which is part of its low-maintenance appeal.
How can I tell St. Augustine and Centipede apart?
Look at the blade width and color. St. Augustine has very wide, dark green blades. Centipede has narrow, light apple-green blades. Also, check the stolons (runners). St. Augustine stolons are thick and fleshy, while Centipede stolons are more slender and flat.
Choosing between these two excellent southern grasses comes down to a honest assessment of your site and your goals. Take your time, consider the key factors of sun, soil, maintenance, and use. With the right grass properly cared for, you’ll have a beautiful, resilient lawn that makes your southern home even more welcoming.